Header graphic for print
China Law Blog China Law for Business

China Law Blog And “What Do You Think?”

Posted in China Business

Whenever I am asked about what I get out of this blog, I never fail to mention something along the lines of “information from our readers.” Both co-blogger Steve Dickinson and I are always talking about how we are the rare lawyers who love our jobs and we both list “learning something new every day” as one of the reasons for that.

When I had been practicing law for around three years, I was offered a prestigious in-house position with THE company in my hometown. I almost took the job, but something someone said from the company made me decide against it. One of the in-house lawyers talked about how much he liked feeling that he had “mastered the company and mastered his work.” I interpreted him to say that his work had become routine and easy and I did not like that comment then and I like it even less now.

My work is not routine and I doubt that it ever will be. Chinese laws are forever changing as is China’s enforcement of them. This means that my firm is constantly having to adjust in terms of the advice we give our clients. On top of that, every client’s situation is going to be at least a little bit different than the others. In other words, we as lawyers cannot get cocky, cannot get tranquil, and cannot remain static and expect to remain at the top of our games. We need to keep on keeping our ears open, keep on learning, and keep on developing our craft. That is what I love about my work and that is what I love about having this blog.

This blog is a great source for our own learning and the comments left by our readers are at the heart of that. We first posed the question, “What do you think?” back in early 2006 and we have posed it thousands of times since then. We do it because we sincerly want your comments. 

When we were just thinking of doing a blog, we drafted a mission statement to help guide us. That statement has barely changed and the following paragraphs imploring comments have not changed at all

It has become a blog cliché to implore readers for their input, but it is so important we must join the crowd on this. We do not purport to know everything about Chinese law. That is impossible. Our strengths are forming companies in China, drafting international contracts with Chinese companies (in English and in Chinese), intellectual property protection and international litigation and arbitration. We welcome your comments, suggestions and ideas on any area of law relating to conducting business in China. China is anything but monolithic and we will be relying in large part on you, our readers, to round out this site with your own stories.

In plain language, we ask that you write us early and often. We will review your comments before we post them, but that does NOT mean you should not criticize us or disagree with us. Our review will be to filter out comments that are without substance and/or personally abusive. We want to encourage a high level of discussion, but we will not ban or delete your comments just because you come after us.

Interestingly but unfortunately, though our readership seems to grow pretty much every month (we are now allegedly the third most read English language law blog and the fifth most influential), the numbers of comments has declined a bit, due in large part (I believe) to the fact that a much greater percentage of our readers view us from their blog readers without ever actually alighting on our site.  Both we and our readers benefit from your comments so please keep ‘em coming.

What do you think?

  • Lo Kok Kee

    Hi Dan,
    You have enough material in your archives for compilation into ‘Chinese laws for Dummies’. Reading your blog is like studying law through night school and after so many years, I think I should have reached the level of the ‘first year law student’, lol.
    Thanks for entertaining and enlightening us when you could be billing your clients at hundreds of dollars an hour instead.

  • http://www.qualityinspection.org Renaud

    I have taken the same habit on my blog. I often ask “do you agree?”, “anybody has other examples?”, “do you agree?”, etc. Very powerful to get comments that enrich the article.
    I have 3 or 4 regular readers who leave a really insightful comment from time to time. It is worth writing just to get their feedback!

  • Annonymously Annonymous

    I actually wish you wouldn’t conclude so many of your posts with “What do you Think?” We don’t need that to know that we can and should leave comments.

  • matt

    I could say that this is the best legal blog on China that I have read, but the truth is that it is probably the best blog on China, period.

  • http://laowaitimes.blogspot.com Mike

    Hi Dan,
    Just want to concur with you that I normally read from Google Reader, and thus don’t often make comments. Also, I find your blog highly informative – I work in media myself – so I’m rarely in a position to really be able to further the discussions. However, I would just like to say that I find your blog highly readable, informative and valuable, so keep it going!

  • neil

    I guess it’s hard sometimes for me to comment meaningfully when I am not involved in China business myself. But it is always good to read others comments, from people who are.

  • http://www.foarp.blogspot.com FOARP

    1) This a good blog, one I read regularly.
    2) The China blogging scene has become subdued ever since large-scale effective blocking was introduced in 2007. Essentially the people who would enjoy commenting most on China blogs, who would build a community of commenters, are forbidden from commenting on most of the English-language China blogs. Whilst I understand that this blog is not blocked, the fate of some of the other commenting hubs (particularly PKD) has destroyed the community which would make most of the comments.
    3) People outside China are less likely to comment because they are less likely to have the requisite experience.

  • Jaap

    Dan,
    The Web is dead (http://www.wired.com/magazine/2010/08/ff_webrip/all/1). The action is in social media and today that is facebook and twitter.
    Your blog is without doubt *the* blog about China and that China focus makes it awkward to switch to twitter or facebook. So maybe this will be the moment to dissolve your blog into a bigger entity with enough momentum to generate user feedback. For now i can imagine you will see increasing traffic because it is the best blog on China and all those readers have less and less places to go elsewhere. But eventually when the RSS readers start disappearing (Google has recently put it’s reader into a geriatric home) this growth will stop.