Header graphic for print
China Law Blog China Law for Business

China And The Economics Of Food.

Posted in China Business

During an interview with Oregon Public Radio the other day, I was asked where I saw the most opportunity for foreign businesses in China. My answer was education, healthcare, food, cleantech/greentech, and software.  It is the same five industries I have been saying for years and the one that always seems to draw the most surprise is food.  

Just as a bit of an aside, I divide the world between food cultures and drinking cultures, based strictly on whether the lawyers/clients in a country plan dinner based on its location between where we were working and where we will be going out drinking or whether dinner is based strictly on food quality. By this criterion, China is a food culture. 

As China grows wealthier, its demand for safe and high quality food is going to continue increasing and foreign companies all along the food chain are well positioned to benefit. Most importantly, food is low risk at least to the extent that we can be certain there will always be at least some demand. And though I do not for a minute purport to have much expertise in Agrarian economics, it does not take a genius to realize that as China becomes more and more urbanized, it is correspondingly going to become less and less agrarian. 

Nomura, Asia’s largest global investment bank, just came out with a report, entitled, The Coming Surge in Food Prices. The report is predicting “another multi-year food price rise, partly because of burgeoning demand from the world’s rapidly developing – and most populated – economies, where diets are changing towards a higher calorie intake.” 

The report then goes on to classify the eighty largest economies on their vulnerability to “a sustained surge in food prices.”  Nomura bases this vulnerability on, among other things, “whether or not the country is rich or poor, or a large net food mporter or exporter” and” in an attempt to gauge the overall impact on an economy, constructed the Nomura Food Vulnerability Index (NFVI), made up of the following three components:

  1. Nominal GDP per capita in USD at market exchange rates.
  2. The share of food in total household consumption.
  3. Net food exports as a percentage of GDP.

The list is on page 27 of the report and it is fascinating. It ranks Bangladesh, Morroco, and Algeria, as the number one, two and three, most vulnerable countries in the world to a surge in food prices, and New Zealand, Uruguay, and Argentina, as the three least vulnerable.  Between these extremes, here are some more ratings, from most to least vulnerable:

  • Hong Kong, 9th most vulnerable
  • Phillipines, 13th most vulnerable
  • India, 21st most vulnerable
  • China, 22nd most vulnerable
  • Vietnam, 24th most vulnerable
  • Indonesia, 32nd most vulnerable
  • South Korea, 40th most vulnerable
  • Singapore, 49th most vulnerable
  • Japan, 53rd most vulnerable
  • Thailand, 55th most vulnerable
  • Malaysia, 64th most vulnerable
  • United States, 67th most vulnerable
  • Canada, 68th most vulnerable
  • Australia, 69th most vulnerable

My sense is that this list is pretty accurate. What do you think?

  • http://www.twitter.com/darnoc darnoc

    This is an important topic that we’ll be hearing a lot more about. I’ll look forward to reading the Nomura report, but some immediate thoughts….the economics of food are increasingly becoming correlated with the economics of energy and related resources. I’ll recommend last week’s Stocktwits MacroWeekly in this regard that talks about Potash becoming the new lever in the geopolitics of food: http://stocktwits.com/macroweekly/FoodFight-September-26-2010.pdf.
    With specific regard to China, it’s important to keep in mind that evolving and growing food demands as noted will result in a competition for global resources. A lot has been written about Africa as a battleground for this competition as countries effectively outsource their production. The Middle East and North Africa will be regions that compete with China in this regard…it’s not surprising to see Morocco and Algeria in the top 3 on Nomura’s list. I’ll bet that Egypt and even Nigeria rank pretty high too….these are also fairly large economies that face similar issues with regard to food economics. You are right, there is plenty of opportunity for foreign companies to play important roles in this value chain…just understand that the value chain is not constrained by national borders.

  • http://www.gweipo.com gweipo

    Interestingly enough in Wing On Department store in Hong Kong, there is a whole section of Taiwanese food (processed not fresh) and they’re marketing themselves as the “safe Chinese food alternative” or words to that effect… so you can have your cake and eat it!

  • T.A.

    This is a fascinating report and I too think it is pretty accurate in its ranking of country vulnerability to food price surges. Let us just hope though that it is wrong in predicting another food price surge soon.

  • http://wangbo.blogtown.co.nz Chris Waugh

    Surely they should’ve added water resources to the components for their index? That would bump both Australia and China, among others, up the list in an unhealthy direction.

  • Andrew Marks

    Food is always going to be a critical component of a country’s economy. We here in the United States can so easily forget that because of our abundant farming. But what is so interesting about this report is to see wealthy (but farm poor) countries like Hong Kong put into the same mix as a poor country like Bangladesh. This report has made me look at food issues from new perspectives.

  • Andrew Marks

    It amazes me how little is being written of this. It is obviously a critical issue and I fear the media is being silent on it because the news is so grim it will lead to violence.

  • Cal

    Food is neglected and I think it is either because so few media people know much about it or what could happen just terrifies them.

  • xteer

    UC Irvine’s Macroeconomics Class by Peter Navarro. Students analyze food quality issues in the United States and China.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LdiRhSPJJlY