Header graphic for print
China Law Blog China Law for Business

China Not Manned Enough For Safety

Posted in China Business, Legal News

CLB’s own Steve Dickinson was interviewed today on National Public Radio’s (NPR) Marketplace show regarding China product safety. The segment was entitled, “China Not Manned Enough for Safety.” The interview was quite short and its transcript follows:

Scott Jagow: Typically, a company like Disney licenses its characters to toy manufacturers. Those toy companies are then in charge of making sure the products are safe.

Well, not anymore. Disney plans to tell toymakers today it’s gonna do its own testing. Plus, on the retail end, Toys “R” US will start doing random checks this week, sending toys off to an independent laboratory. These new precautions are, of course, in response to Mattel’s huge recalls of toys made in China.

In Washington today, the Consumer Product Safety Commission holds a hearing on this. And safety regulators from Beijing will be there. More now from our China correspondent, Scott Tong.

Scott Tong: Chinese regulators have sat on the hot seat for months, facing demands that they ensure the safety of all Chinese exports. But:

Steve Dickinson: The Chinese government doesn’t have the power, or the manpower, to do that.

Scott Tong: That’s China attorney Steve Dickinson from the international law firm of Harris Moure. He says in China’s decentralized economy with thousands of suppliers, Beijing has a limited means to carry out its mandates.

Dickinson thinks responsibility lies with the U.S. toy companies who can often dictate prices to their Chinese suppliers. Lately, he thinks those multinationals have pushed those prices down too far.

Steve Dickinson: If you’re in business, you know if the price is too low. And if you know the supplier can’t make it, then you also have to know the supplier’s doing something to survive.

Scott Tong: For instance, cutting corners and substituting unsafe materials like lead paint.
In Shanghai, I’m Scott Tong for Marketplace.

For more on Steve’s views on China, check out this post on the Transnational Law Blog, entitled, “Steve Dickinson Discusses China Law.

  • David Li

    I heard the podcast but I didn’t realize that was Steve. There is a nice piece on Slate (http://www.slate.com/id/2173733/ ) about how toy multinationals have been ignoring the US regulation in place for toy safety.

  • Law Office of Todd L. Platek

    Thanks, Steve, for telling it like it is. The law is the law. “Who you know” is very entertaining, but for the long haul, do it legally. It’s all in the execution.

  • http://www.whataboutclients.com/archives/2007/09/china_law_blog_3.html What About Clients?

    China Law Blog: “Toying with China”

    It’s at Dan Harris’s award-wining China Law Blog. See/hear also “China Not Manned Enough for Safety” and the NPR “Marketplace” interview with Dan’s law partner Steve Dickinson….

  • http://www.whataboutclients.com/archives/2007/09/toying_with_chi.html What About Clients?

    “Toying with China”

    It’s at Dan Harris’s award-wining China Law Blog. See/hear also “China Not Manned Enough for Safety” and the NPR “Marketplace” interview with Dan’s law partner Steve Dickinson….

  • http://www.whataboutclients.com/archives/2007/09/toying_with_chi_1.html What About Clients?

    “Toying with China”

    It’s at Dan Harris’s award-winning China Law Blog. See/hear also “China Not Manned Enough for Safety” and the NPR “Marketplace” interview with Dan’s law partner Steve Dickinson….