Korea, Fake Degrees, Confucius, Due Diligence, And China Too
Big scandal going on in Korea right now where many leading public figures are being forced to come clean for having lied about their degrees. Korea Law Blog just did a post, entitled, "More on the Fake Degree Scandal," explaining why this is happening and what employers should be doing about it. Just substitute Chinese for Korean and China for Korea and it applies to China.
KLB starts out describing the problem:
Fakes are endemic in Korean corporations, says the International Herald-Tribune yesterday. And we’re not talking about fake handbags—society is grappling with the problem of fake people who claim degrees they don’t have.How do all these fakes get themselves hired? And why do Korean employers emphasize the degree to such an extent? According to the IHT, it’s because employment background checks are useless:
Although some companies conduct their own aptitude tests to detect the best job candidates, the dependence on academic degrees persists.
The post goes on to quote from the IHT article on how personal recommendations are seldom useful because when Koreans talk about other people, they tend to focus only on their good points.
KLB states that his experience tells him "that the idea of the 'worthless' background check is overstated.
The truth is, while the critics are correct in that former employers are reluctant to offer frank comments on a past employee, in our practice we often find that the background check is not done at all. And that failure allows the real fakers—those who never went to the university they claim, who overstate their degree, or who claim work experience they don’t actually have—to get in.
KLB's advice is to "slow down, and double-check everything. Speed kills."
For China too.
http://www.chinalawblog.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-t.cgi/2121
Korea, Fake Degrees, Confucius, Due Diligence, And China Too:


Comments
In my 11 years in China, I have hired around 450 people and I personnally interviewed 3 times that amount. It is true that there is a lot of people cheating on their academic diplomas but during interview you almost can see that the applicant doesn't have the skills he pretends to have. What annoys me the most is that some applicants spend so much in making/buying fake diplomas they should better spend that time in studying. The competition among Chinese is so high for jobs that they do not limit themselves by lying on their academic knowledge.
Posted by: Romain Guerel (French moving back to Shanghai) | August 30, 2007 3:13 AM
This seems to me to have gone far. When you make allegations, remember to back it up with evidence...
When you talk about Korea, you use evidence against Korea; when you talk about China you should use evidence against China, right?
Posted by: Jim | August 30, 2007 5:18 AM
This problem is not limited to China and Korea, many Japanese naievely buy "degrees" from degree mills then cite them in resumes and even event bios. I recently had to explain to a high profile Japanese insurance brokerage executive that his claimed PhD in his bio for an event where we both spoke at was issued from a famous west coast degree mill and that he should stop citing it if he wanted to continue on the same circuit. He showed up indignantly with his "coursework" and naievely replied to my two questions "How much did it cost you?" and "How long did the 'doctorate' take?" with "$20K" and "3 months", respectively. What surprised me was that his boss, the Japanese company president, even if he understood the facts, was reluctant to ask his to drop the "doctorate" from his bio, and there was no mention of any sanctions. The US parent is NYSE listed.
Posted by: Mike O`Keeffe | August 30, 2007 7:47 AM