Beware The China Joint Venture, But Do Not Ignore It Completely

The other day I did a post, entitled, "Beware The China Joint Venture," where I again railed against doing joint ventures in China.  It listed six  of my previous posts highlighting problems with joint ventures. Kent Kedl, of Technomic Asia, which describes itself as "a strategic consultancy firm whose mission is to assist globally-expanding companies to build their Asian businesses through high quality market strategy and implementation assistance," left a great comment.

Mr. Kedl analogizes joint ventures to marriages and says that just as a high divorce rate does not mean all marriages are bad, so too the high rate of joint venture failures does not mean all joint ventures are bad.  I completely agree, but note the rate of bad joint ventures seems to exceed that of bad marriages. 

Mr. Kedl really shines in pointing out the two most common ways companies fail in their joint ventures:

In 20 years of doing China market entry and growth strategy work, we have seen our shares of VERY bad JVs (and participated setting up a couple of them in the very early years) and have concluded that foreign companies most often fail in two ways:

1. They see a JV as their "China strategy." A JV is NOT a strategy: it is a tool to realize your China strategy (which should be expressed as "We are going after China growth opportunities in Market X with Product Y through Distribution Channels A, B & C and defending ourselves against Competitors D, E & F"). The JV should be seen as only one option for how to realize this strategy. China is becoming more open every year to creative structures so a potential JV should be compared to many other options...and chosen ONLY when it is the best way to realize your identified strategy.

2. The second way companies fail in China JVs is to "marry their first date." Honestly, too many times have companies approached us saying "we want to do a JV with this company that we just met at a trade show." One U.S. company we know tried to force-fit a JV with a Chinese company like this and (thankfully) gave up after trying for two years. We started over with them again, confirming and validating their China strategy (see above) and, once we determined that our strategy required a JV of some kind, then looked at over 250 different companies before settling on 4 companies to do some serious due-diligence on and then, finally, one to begin negotiations with. By this time they were confident that a JV structure was for them, they knew EXACTLY what it needed to look like in order to work, and they had (as much as can be expected) confidence that they had found the right partner.

So true.