China -- Damn The Joint Venture
China Business Services Blog just did a short post on joint ventures (JV), entitled, "Don't Quote Me (on Joint Ventures)." Regular readers know I am generally not a fan of joint ventures. Yes, they are sometimes necessary, but when they are not, they are to be avoided. What you can get out of a joint venture you can almost always get out of a contract as well, without the oftentimes devastating entanglements. For more on this, check out To Succeed In China Know The Now, The Asianist Knows China, When In China, Don't Get Screwed -- The Movie, and the one that started it all, WFOE v. JV.
The China Business Blog's post consisted entirely of the following quote from Alan Brown, Unilever's head guy in China, responding to a question whether to have a joint venture in China:
'If you are working in a highly regulated industry, then JV partners are almost essential'If you are working in a highly deregulated industry, they can be a damn nuisance'.
Well put. But, for those still considering a joint venture, this CEIBS (China Europe International Business School) article, "To JV, or Not to JV - How MNCs Choose Local Partners?" makes a nice starting point for the various strategies one might use in picking the right one.
http://www.chinalawblog.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-t.cgi/1328
» James McGregor's China Tips China Law Blog
Long ago, The Wall Street Journal reviewed James McGregor's book, One Billion Customers. The review had a sidebar, entitled, Crib Sheet, listing various tips from the book, including the following: The Chinese will ask you for anything because you just []
» China's Joint Venture Jeopardy China Law Blog
The Wall Street Journal just ran an article I wrote, entitled, "Joint Venture Jeopardy". It is on the Danone-Wahaha dispute and it gives a few basics for avoiding joint venture problems. For those of you coming here for the first ... []
» Danone v. Wahaha -- Which Of Us Is The Most China Rookie? China Law Blog
'You sit by yourself grasshopper. What do you think of?' -Master Po 'My mother, my father. Both gone. I am alone.' 'You hear the flock of birds flying overhead? You hear the fish? The beetle?' To all of this the young Caine nods. 'In this crowded place... []
» China SMEs -- Own If You Want To Own China Law Blog
In the song, "Positive Vibrations," Bob Marley sang, "Live if you want to live." On AmchamDaily's blog, Jeremy Goldkorn says if you want to own something in China, you have to make sure you own it. Marley and Goldkorn both speak great truths. AmCham Da... []
» Let's Rag Some More On China Joint Ventures China Law Blog
As regular readers of this blog know, we are not big fans of Chinese joint ventures. Yes, sometimes they are necessary, and yes, sometimes they even make sense. But most of the time, a strong contract can achieve the same thing with far less potential ... []
» Clissold v. McGregor In China Business Smackdown. China Law Blog
Bizcult has a post up, entitled, "Old China Hands Face Off in Knowledge Duel", highlighting the following nuggets from a podcast of James McGregor (One Billion Customers) and Tim Clissold (Mr. China): Read the Five Year Plan. The government gives you “... []
» China Joint Ventures. Can Things Get Any Worse? China Law Blog
When I was just starting out as a lawyer, I negotiated what I thought was a great settlement for my client. The amount it would pay would be far less than we were expecting it would take to settle, and the other side would be giving us a more complete ... []
